Pharmaceutical companies looking to protect their intellectual property in India will be none too pleased with a ruling today by the country’s Supreme Court. It found that Novartis AG’s Gleevec cancer drug wasn’t innovative enough to be awarded a patent, upholding regulatory rulings from 2006 to the present that found the same. This means that drug makers in India can continue selling generic versions of Gleevec.
Novartis argued that it invested years of research into Gleevec, specifically on modifying the molecule imatinib, to make it a safe treatment for leukemia. In denying Novartis’s patent application in 2006, the Indian Patent Office relied on a section of Indian law forbidding “evergreening,” or slightly changing the chemical makeup of a drug to extend its patent life without adding any medical benefits. Novartis appealed this decision to India’s Supreme Court, only to have it affirmed.