Litigation: Neutralizing the putative lead plaintiff

Different circuits set different precedents on whether offers of judgment moot class action complaints

In two recent cases—Damasco v. Clearwire Corp. and Pitts v. Terrible Herbst, Inc—the 7th and 9th Circuits, respectively, reached conflicting results on the issue of whether an offer of judgment for the full amount of a putative lead plaintiff’s own claim moots a class action complaint if the offer predates the plaintiff’s filing of a motion to certify the action as a class. While the 7th Circuit opinion provides a road map for plaintiffs’ counsel to avoid the practical results of the ruling, it may provide certain opportunities for defendants to neutralize the putative lead plaintiff.

In Pitts, the putative lead plaintiff in a wage and hour case claimed $88in damages for himself. Prior to Pitts moving for class certification, defendant Terrible Herbst made an offer of judgment under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 68, for $900 plus costs and a reasonable attorney’s fee. Pitts rejected the offer.

In Damasco, the putative lead plaintiff filed a class action complaint against defendant Clearwire, alleging a violation of the Telephone Consumer Protection Act, and seeking treble damages of $1500 for each alleged unsolicited text message to mobile subscribers. Prior to Damasco moving for class certification, Clearwire made an offer to pay him his entire $1500 claim for damages, as well court costs. Damasco never responded to the offer. Clearwire then removed the case, and moved to dismiss on mootness grounds.

The district court granted the motion to dismiss, relying on Holstein, a prior 7th Circuit decision that held an offer of judgment moots a putative class action unless the lead plaintiff moved for class certification prior to the offer being made.

author image

Donna Wilson

Donna L. Wilson is a partner in the Los Angeles office of BuckleySandler LLP where she leads the firm’s West Coast litigation practice, with a...

Bio and more articles

Join the Conversation

Advertisement. Closing in 15 seconds.